
Seconds later, we are introduced to the blockage - its a foot bearing sneakers with an orange sole. And behind it is the smiling face of Rajnikanth.

After that rather delirious opening sequence, Chandramukhi sort of falls apart as a movie save for one gorgeous kite flying song (which ends with the kites forming the words "Superstar" in the sky). The reason is really in the execution of its genre: horror-comedy.

So back to our man. With dancing skills in Amitabh Bachchan territory, Rajni nevertheless has this wonderful little smile going that sits really well below his curiously feathered wig. Its a knowing smile - as if to say: I know I'm like a bad habit you can't break, so here we go. He also has a rather terrific slit eyed look which he sadly under utilizes in this movie.
Somewhere in the middle is a confounding taming of the shrew sequence. It works like this: Rajni acts like a juvenile and annoys the heck out of a young village belle (Nayanthara) in a song. This includes twirling a fake CGI kite on his finger and placing it on Nayanthara's head.

Fortunately Jyothika is around to rescue us. She looks devastatingly good in a saree and choti and acts deliciously over the top which give this movie legs to tide it over the times when Rajni decides to prance off the screen.
Also:
- Amrita draws attention to one killer dance
- Never Mind!! hears Akshay wasn't half as good as Thalaivar
- leera has seen Rajni only once - in a Hindi movie
- Bitterlemons can't stand Rajni but recommends a Jyothika movie
- Pitu hears Vidya Balan did the finale well in the remake
- Lin can't watch Rajni but links to the final dance version in Malayalam and Kannada
- Lata P reveals the complexity of Rajni's dialogs
- Joules thinks Shobhana rocks but has only seen the Hindi remake
- Mind Rush on the difference between a psychiatrist and a psychologist (Aspi, you idiot)
- Sidekick explains "athey athey" and the cult of personality
33 comments:
"Chutiya", u mean choti, not chutiya, isnt it? Chutiya is a gross word, son.
Hail Rajni,
East or west Superstar Rajni is the Best.
Fair enough, I corrected it mostly because I don't want a bunch of people stopping by the site for the wrong reasons :)
But I wonder if I had spelt it chuttiya, would it have been ok? Hmmm.
Excuse me, did you write a post on Chandramukhi without mentioning the true horror of this movie: Jyothika's dancing?
Goose lover and dance ignore-er... why, Aspi, why?!
Wow, is this the movie that bhool bhulaiya was inspired from? Regardless, anyone in that loony psychologist role would have been less annoying than Akshay Kumar.
I have only seen Rajnikant in Hindi movies, namely Chaalbaaz which I really liked him in. You are right about the angelic smile, Aspi, very endearing inspite of the hairpieces.
Do enlighten us on the horrors of Jyothika's dancing, Amrita. Is there a clip out there somewhere?
Missed this movie. I did see BHool Bhulaiyya and heard Akshay Kumar is not even half as good as Thalaivar!
leera, the final Jyothika dance in Chandramukhi that Amrita is referring to can be seen here. Watch at your own peril.
Although you have to love Prabhu's WTF expression whenever he sees his wife.
Aspi,
this is heroism WAY beyond the call of Duty! I'll probably get lynched or something, but Rajni I CANNOT stand, in ANY movie...unfortunately, married into a family which thinks he is God! :-D (I understand he is a very nice person IRL, and have no issues with him as a person otherwise!)
Amrita, I actually thought Jyothika did fine in that role...including her dancing (lack of!) - seemed to fit the role well..but then, I love Jyothika in anything she does....
BTW, if any readers want a good Jyothika movie, watch Mozhi (Tamil) - very nice movie, done well.
Bitterlemons
O haha Jyothika's dance was sad! I thought Vidya did a great job in the Bhool Bhulaiyya song.
I'm with Bitterlemons. I clicked on the Kite song and was watching and enjoying it till Rajni showed up. After about two seconds, I clicked out of YouTube. I just can't stand to watch the guy. I honestly don't get his appeal on screen.
And speaking of the dance.
Shobana in the Malayalam version
http://youtube.com/watch?v=7595g5Bipfw
and Soundarya in the Kannada one
http://youtube.com/watch?v=6spSwq65z64
This is one of the best movies.Every body performed well. I think this was one of the best performance of Jyotika. One thing about Rajni movies is the dialogues he delivers. Most of them are like hitting 2 birds with one stone. Like in movie "Muthu" he asks where the Lady of the house is? The servants tell him that she has gone to temple. And in that movie the Lady had a small temple in her courtyard. So Rajni says God is right in her court yard and she is looking for it outside.Well Aspi you definitely deserve a praise for venturing out and watching other state movies.
Leera - after watching Jyothika, watch Shobhana. You shall see the diff.
Bitterlemons - yeah, i've never been able to get on the Jyothika bandwagon although Chandramukhi was the first role of hers where I went "wtf?!" Thing is, I saw Shobhana in that role first and she casts a loooong shadow. she totally nailed that imagination/reality thing and of course, she's shobhana!
Aspi - watch Manichitratazhu!
Good to see Shobhana. Haven't seen her since Mitr my friend. I think she is one of the most beautiful indian faces. She looks beautiful even in the crazy act.
I actually enjoyed BB and Vidya's role. The hindi version is the only one I have seen. It is very interesting to see a scene acted in different languages by different actresses.
Wow even with the warning the Jyothika clip made me jump up and spill water all over my lap. Ramsay brothers are you watching?
I am with you Amrita and joules, Shobhana wins this one hands down. That was the only one that realistically looked like a mental illness. Vidya was good but both the hindi and the tamil ones suffered from too much shock value in their potrayals.
I must thank Amrita profusely here - how could I have missed that tremendous dance, I must have fallen asleep.
Now that I've see it - I'm going to watch it again on DVD.
Thanks for the other links everyone - its fascinating to watch the other versions.
Driftji,
Hillarious review. Esp. enjoyed your captioning the mysogynistic dialogues.
One piece of errata...I thought Rajni played a psychiatrist, an MD doc, not a psychologist, (i.e. a Ph.D.) Regardless, the film butchered shrinks. The whole thing about literally "reading minds" was SOO ridiculous.
Aspi, you've adopted regional cinema in big way :) - waah, hilarious caps esp. the jyothika -prabhu one. the self-referential character of Rajini's films is his signature.... if you can't enjoy it, well then like bitterlemons, u'll hate his films ;). i think somewhere you'd asked abt "athey, athey" ("that is it, that is it" in tamil) being repeated - that's part of the so called rajini style. there's usually a line/catch phrase that becomes the refrain for his character in every movie. plenty of tamil heroes build their careers around the cult of personality usually as a prelude to a political career, but no one more so than rajini in terms of sheer exuberance and audacity. But i can see why it doesn't fly with a lot of folks. bitterlemons, i thought rajini made a pretty credible villain in his early balachander films.
all told i agree with mind rush: this is a pretty sorry excuse of a movie. not sure if the depiction of mental illness and psychiatry is simply laughable or also insulting!
as for the various leading ladies - as a dancer it isn't even fair to compare shobhana with the others. shobhana is a trained bharatanatyam dancer who is still at the top of her game. usually i like jyothika just fine, but in this movie, got to agree with amrita, she was just awful.
aspi, i'm curious which version u watched - tamil or telugu. u've linked us to the telugu version for the opening sequence and to the tamil version for the kite song. fm yr perspective i guess its all the same - they're both subtitled in English.
sidekick, thanks for the explanation. Given I heard "Athey" its probably the Tamil version. But I had no idea what I was linking to - I can't tell the difference yet. Hopefully one day :)
But I'm glad you pointed that out - a nuance I would have missed.
What is the deal with getting Tamil movies subtitled around here? I don't like watching dubbed flicks so its a real loss for me.
i saw 5 mins of this movie and cudn't stand it anymore.maybe bcos i love the malayalam version too much.Shobana was fabulous!
Sidekick,
you're right, Rajni as villan is way better than Rajni as hero..and yes, the whole Rajni cult thing irritates the heck out of me, which contributes to my irritation at his acting.
Amrita, OK, I'll grant you Shobana over Jyothika any day for dance skills, Shobana *is* a trained dancer :-) And yes, the Malayalam version of the movie is the best one around. There is also a Kannada version.
I think the progression was Malayalam -> Tamil -> Telugu -> Kannada -> Hindi.
Aspi, not sure what your comment abt subtitles in Tamil movies was - do you not get them subtitled? Ayngaran DVDs have very decent subtitles as a rule, not sure which other DVD makers subtitle Tamil movies. I haven't seen movies in languages that I don't understand, so kudos to you for trying to watch with subtitles!
Bitterlemons
Well, most of the stores I go to say they don't have Tamil movies with subtitles. So not sure why now that you tell me it shouldn't be an issue.
I've always been extremely fond of South Indian films. Now I have the means to do so - and more importantly some great recommendations from all of you.
But in general, the infusion of culture (from an emotional perspective) is always the fascinating aspect of watching any phoren language film.
For example, it astonished me how Guillermo Del Toro made Pan's Labyrinth and I can't imagine say a French director making it with the same sensibility even though the movie is Spanish and France is closer to Spain than Mexico is.
So if you watch a lot of movies like me then you get jaded enough that you want to look for something different. However I stick with fairly mainstream movies when dipping outside Hindi/English. I'm not hugely arty per se - although that interpretation might vary.
Oh, forgot. I think Pan's Labyrinth is one of the finest films I've seen (and I didn't even get half the metaphors) and might even go down as one of the great films made in our times. But unless you have a cast iron stomach for gore - I would recommend skipping it.
Its the reason I kept it away from the Drift memsaab and watched it by myself.
Pan's was amazing! Ajit and I saw it the day of its release and it was just breathtaking. And oooo the lead actor was sooo yummy looking :-D What is it about men in uniform? :-p
Count me amongst those who loved Pan's, although I watched large parts of it thru the cracks of my fingers! Given that I love getting to the creative impetus, I found this interview terrific and if you liked the films of the 3 mexican amigos that year, then you may also enjoy this one.
Terrific link that interview. You have to love that earthy Mexican humor which leaves Charlie Rose confounded on more than one occasion.
And yes, many scenes in Pan's were watched from the cracks of my fingers. Particularly that one where one character stitches his lips (how DID they do that?)
Yep, that lip stitching scene still brings shudders.
Also meant to rant on my big peeve (among many!) with Chandramukhi/BB on how poorly classical dancing is depicted. I get that Bollywood dancing is hugely popular and has evolved into its own form, but really when the script calls for a classical dancer as in this case would it be so hard to shoot it authentically? --- a proper 4-5 minute Kuchipudi piece in Chandramukhi and an Odissi one in BB.
Granted it isn't easy to find a Shobana who can both dance expertly and act splendidly but surely it is possible to shoot top shots of hand movements which these actresses can do and then the footwork separately by trained dancers. Also long shots with real dancers for some of the flow. In all fairness, in BB there was some of this and it got much better when Vineet who is classically trained joined Vidya in the dance. In Chandramukhi though there wasn't even a pretense of getting Kuchipudi right.
I can't tell whats Kuchipudi and whats Bharat Natyam (although I can pick out Odissi because the Drift Memsaab used to dabble in it). But I enjoyed the lesson.
But I feel BB has the most sophisticated camera work of all the flicks as far as that dance is concerned and it probably goes a long way in making the dance look good. They've actually put their dolly to good use unlike the other picturizations.
Collection of Actress Nayanthara Photos and Videos ,Gallery, Wallpapers,
Latest movies, only at www.nayantharamovies.com
ramesh, man, she looks so different on that site compared to the movie.
Wish some of the links were functional on that site - I always enjoy linking to fan sites of actors/actresses instead of wikipedia or IMDB entries.
Collection of Actress Nayantara Photos and Videos ,Gallery, Wallpapers, Latest movies,
only at http://www.nayantharamovies.com
hey
Always mallus have pride in them and can never accept facts. Original is always best but the fact that Tamil audience are very much different compared to Malayalam audience is to be understood before criticising.Many of those who cannot stand Rajni are the ones who goes and sees his movies but their pride does not permit them to accept. Just one question to these I....s Do they think they are more brilliant to guage the talent of Superstar than Balachandar,Sridhar,Bharatiraja,Shankar and ManiRatnam ??????? and the enormous number of fans worldwide irrespective of religion,caste,education, status and so on.
Just shut up.
Man, I liked it better when people stopped by and forwarded us to pictures of Nayantara.
Anon, you took this too seriously yaar. Instead tell us which Rajni movie I should watch next. I'm always looking for recommendations.
To the criticizers of the various versions - Dont forget that the orginal version in Malayalam(Manichitrathazhu) came in 1993. that was more than 10 years before the remakes. And ofcourse the technologies in movie industries have advanced a lott. The remakes have that advantage.
Post a Comment